HOUSTON — A federal jury has awarded $13 million in damages to the family of Charles Payne, a 75-year-old man who died in a collision with a Houston Police Department vehicle in December 2021.
The jury found that the City of Houston’s policies allowed officers to drive recklessly, calling them “the moving force” behind Payne’s death and violation of his constitutional rights. The court also ruled that the city “was deliberately indifferent” in adopting an “inadequate” policy.
According to court documents, Payne was attempting a left turn on North Shepherd Drive when HPD Officer Christopher Cabrera, driving at more than 70 mph in a 35 mph zone and not responding to an emergency call, struck Payne’s vehicle. Cabrera, initially listed as a defendant, was later granted qualified immunity.
Attorneys Ben Crump and Paul Grinke, representing Payne’s family, said the verdict acknowledges the truth of what happened. “This verdict cannot erase the overwhelming pain of losing him, but it is an important measure of justice for his family,” the statement read. They added that they hope the ruling will encourage stronger police vehicle safety policies.
Houston City Attorney Arturo Michel said the city respects the jury’s work but is reviewing the case for a possible appeal. The city has 30 days to pursue legal action.